Declining US superstores turn to social media to reverse trend![]()
Wal-Mart Stores and Sears Holdings Corp. are suffering uncomfortable media comparisons. Both are grandfathers of the retail sector, both have historically been giants and innovators. And now both are squirming due to declining revenues and a lack of concentration on where the customer buck is going.
As is often the case with big, long established companies, they have been watching each other to ensure they are keeping up. Unfortunately both Wal-Mart and Sears, while keeping track of the couch pototo, head in the sand inactivity of the other, failed to notice that newcomers were stealing their customers.
Sears Holdings reported a decline in revenue of 1.6% to $43.3 billion for fiscal year 2010, and Wal-Mart Stores reported sales at discount stores and U.S. same-store sales declined in 2009 and 2010. As a result of these failures, Wal-Mart’s e-commerce chief resigned in August and David Friedman, Sears’ SVP and president of marketing, will resign his post in January.
Both companies are now trying to drag their online activities, including social media and e-commerce communications, into the 21st century, but as with Kodak, it may be a case of too little, too late.
Online clutter
There is much to do. As well as the signature Walmart and Sears brands, Wal-Mart Stores owns and operates four subsidiaries, including Sam’s Club, and Sears Holdings owns and operates five subsidiaries, including Kmart.
With nine product offers available and more than 20 clickable tabs, Walmart brand’s e-commerce site is cluttered. It is still marketing in the time-honoured fashion of email newsletter registration, local ads and daily deals. It integrates social media onto product landing pages as well as the homepage, but it smacks of lipservice to the technology, rather than a well thought through strategy.
“Walmart’s [e-commerce strategy] is stack-em-high-and-let-em-fly,” says Laura Saati, VP of strategic marketing services at marketing agency 89 Degrees. “I liked the opportunity Walmart gave me to ‘like’ the product as I was placing it in my cart. I loved that they had a call-out to sign up for email when viewing the Black Friday circular.”
Online review
Kara Trivunovic, global director of strategy for the Agency Services division of StrongMail, a social media and email marketing technology services provider, says both sites are well-organized and offer similar left-rail and upper-navigation bar layouts. However, she says she found Walmart’s clutter to be distracting.
Both brands are now trying hard with social media. Walmart launched 3,500 store-specific Facebook pages in October that enable consumers to receive offers and updates from local retail locations. In addition to these offers, Walmart goes out of its way to interact with and engage social customers.
Walmart also has new iPhone app and there is a “feedback” tab on the Facebook page for users to ask questions and share ideas.
Sears is given credit for making direct offers via its eGift functionality on Facebook, but for shee numbers, Walmart still has the edge. Its 10 million fans outnumber Sears’s fans 10-to-one.
Direct mail
Sears still reigns as a mail order catalogue provider. On the company’s e-commerce page, a tab is dedicated to the Sears brand catalog, as well as each catalog underneath the Sears family umbrella, all of which can be ordered or viewed online. Consumers can also click on local weekly ads to browse the current circular for their nearest retail location.
Reward failure
Walmart fails dramatically when it comes to loyalty rewards. Unlike Sears, which features the dynamic “Shop Your Way Rewards” programme, Walmart offers only the Walmart credit card. The standard card offers bonuses, such as 10-cent savings per gallon at all participating Walmart gas stations and cash advances at time of purchase.
The retailer also offers a Walmart Discover card to cardholders that are eligible, but additional rewards for Discover cardholders only amount to 1% cash back on all purchases.
Sears, however, provides loyalty program members with points for every dollar spent. Shop Your Way Rewards members also have access to special deals unavailable to the general public, and special offers, such as holiday promotion, allow members to earn double rewards for dollars spent.
Walmart has always been set against loyalty rewards as a concept, but it will be interesting to see if it caves in to pressure, and decides that its ten million loyal customers may not stay that way indefinitely without a little extra something. Especially in these challenging times.