Emotional engagement now the main driver of loyalty
Findings from 2013 Brand Keys Engagement Index
Emotional engagement is now the critical factor in driving brand loyalty, according to US company Brand Keys.
The consultancy’s 2013 Customer Loyalty Engagement Index has found that the combination of consumer empowerment via the internet and social networking, ever-inflating consumer expectations, and experience with price promotions and discounting have finally reached saturation-levels, triggering a tipping point in the branded world, where emotional engagement is the dominant driver of purchase decisions and brand loyalty.
Samsung was one of the most successful brands in the survey for emotional engagement, taking the number 1 spot from Apple in the Smartphone category.
Apple had a relatively bad year, also losing the number 1 spot to Amazon in the Tablet category, while Amazon kept its top ranking for E-readers. Also doing well were Hyundai and Ford which tied for number 1 in the Automotive category.
The common factor in all the successful brands was a high level of emotional engagement, according to Brand Keys.
“It should come as no any surprise to marketers that consumers seek greater levels of emotional engagement with products and services they stick with and make profitable,” said Robert Passikoff, president of Brand Keys. “The rule of thumb should be to view the decision process to buy a brand – and then buy it again – as more emotional than it is rational. Estimates for most categories report a 70:30 ratio.
“Marketers have made some initial stabs at trying to understand emotional engagement via flavor-of-the moment approaches like neuromarketing and brain activity measures, which are assumptive and aren’t really generalisable, and none of it identifies what products and services need to do to remain successful brands.”
Below are the brands with highest levels of consumer engagement in their respective categories. The percentages indicate the emotional engagement strength achieved versus a consumer-generated, category-specific Ideal, calculated to be 100%.
Highest Levels of Consumer Engagement by Category
Airline: US Airways (85%)
Athletic Footwear: Sketchers (86%)
Automotive: Ford/Hyundai (93%)
Bank: JP Morgan Chase (79%)
Beer (Light): Coors Light (89%)
Beer (Regular): Coors/Sam Adams (90%)
Breakfast Cereal: Cheerios (91%)
Car Insurance: State Farm (82%)
Car Rental: Avis (92%)
Casual Dining: Applebee’s (82%)
Coffee: Dunkin’ Donuts (90%)
Computer (Laptops): Samsung (91%)
Cosmetics (Luxury): Clinique (93%)
Credit Card; Discover (94%)
Diapers: Pampers (95%)
E-Readers: Kindle (92%)
Evening News Shows: ABC (97%)
Flat Screen TV: Samsung (88%)
Gasoline: Shell (89%)
Hotel (Luxury): Inter-Continental (82%)
Hotel (Upscale): Hilton/Marriott (81%)
Hotel (Midscale): Best Western (86%)
Hotel (Economy): Days Inn (88%)
Insurance: New York Life (81%)
Major League Gaming: Call of Duty – Modern Warfare (93%)
Major League Sports: National Football League (86%)
MFP Office Copier: Canon/Konica Minolta (81%)
Morning News Show: Good Morning, America (ABC) (94%)
Mutual Funds: American Funds (79%)
Natural Food Stores: Whole Foods (93%)
Online Brokerage: Fidelity.com (85%)
Online Retailers: Amazon (96%)
Online Travel Sites: Expedia (88%)
Packaged Coffee: Dunkin’ (95%)
Parcel Delivery: UPS (87%)
Pet Food (Canned) for Cats: Fancy Feast (93%)
Pet Food (Canned) for Dogs: Cesar (94%)
Pizza: Domino’s (84%)
Printers: Canon (88%)
Quick-Serve Restaurants: Subway (95%)
Retail Store (Apparel): J. Crew (82%)
Retail Store (Department): Kohl’s (80%)
Retail Store (Discount): Walmart (89%)
Retail Store (Home Improvement): Home Depot (90%)
Retail Store (Sporting/Recreational Goods): Dick’s (83%)
Search Engine: Google (85%)
Smartphones: Samsung (87%)
Social Networking Sites: Facebook (88%)
Soft Drinks (Diet): Diet Coke (89%)
Soft Drink (Regular): Coke (90%)
Tablets: Amazon (92%)
Toothpaste: Colgate (94%)
Vodka: Grey Goose (91%)
Wireless Phone Service: AT&T (87%)
“Real brand loyalty and emotional engagement is still the Holy Grail of marketing,” said passikoff. “Loyalty is still a leading-indicator of consumer behavior and profitability. Brand power is one of the first measures of competitive advantage that investors seek, since companies that can leverage their brand always profit from long-lasting customer loyalty that drives sales,” said Passikoff.