Retail bank satisfaction increases in 2011
First Direct ranks highest with UK customers
Despite an environment of cynicism toward banks, overall satisfaction with retail banks in the UK has increased from 2010, according to the J.D. Power and Associates 2011 UK Retail Banking Satisfaction Study.
The study by the German marketing services company measures customer satisfaction with banks in the UK based on six factors that drive overall satisfaction: problem resolution; account activities; fees; product offerings; account information; and branch facility.
Overall satisfaction among retail banking customers averages 698 on a 1,000-point scale, up from 683 in 2010. A considerable increase in satisfaction with the branch facility factor has helped drive this improvement. However, satisfaction remains relatively low in three key factors: fees, product offerings and problem resolution.
“It appears that banks have taken action to improve the customer experience, and this effort has paid off,” said Stuart Crawford-Browne, director of the services and emerging industries division at J.D. Power and Associates. “However, retail banks in the UK are still not consistently delivering on customer pain points, such as fees, problems and complaints.”
Negative impact of problems remains
While overall problem incidence declines slightly from 2010, with 19% of retail banking customers experiencing a problem in the past year (compared with 21% in 2010), the negative impact of problems remains large. In fact, 25% of customers who have experienced a problem during the past 12 months say they “definitely will” or “probably will” switch institutions in the next year, while just 8% of customers who have experienced a problem say the same. More than one-half (55%) of customers who have had a problem or complaint say they are disappointed with the resolution process.
The study finds that problems with poor customer service, fees and service charges have a substantial negative impact on overall satisfaction. In addition, customers who experience a problem are considerably more likely to indicate that their fee structure has changed in the past year (30%, compared with 14% of customers who did not have a problem).
“Retail banking customers tend to be especially dissatisfied with overdraft fees and monthly service charges, particularly the amount of these fees,” said Crawford-Browne. “It’s important for banks to clearly articulate the value customers receive through the benefits, services and features of their banking relationship as a way to mitigate some of the negative sentiment caused by a monthly service fee or overdraft fee.”
The study also finds that while incentives are important in attracting new customers, customer service is key to retention. Fifteen per cent of customers say that they selected a particular bank because of an incentive, such as a promotional gift or cash award. However, nearly 40% of customers left their bank because of a poor service experience, and an additional 43% cite poor service as a top reason for intending to leave their bank.
“While incentives have the short-term benefits of attracting business, that business can go out the back door just as quickly as it comes through the front door if banks aren’t delivering a solid customer experience,” said Crawford-Browne. “Relying on incentives only works if customers are highly satisfied. Banks can reap the benefits of high recommendation and retention rates when customers are satisfied with the service they receive.”
First Direct ranks highest in customer satisfaction with a score of 774, followed by The Co-operative Bank (734) and Nationwide (723). First Direct performs particularly well in four of the six factors: account activities; account information; product offerings; and fees.
The 2011 UK Retail Banking Satisfaction Study is based on responses from 3,899 customers of banks throughout the UK. The study was fielded in September and October 2011.